You may wonder what are the pros and cons of freestanding bathtubs (open on all sides) and alcove bathtubs (between two or three walls)? Which is the best one for my family?

In this article, my goal is simple. I would like to introduce the pros and cons of them, so that you can find the right choice for you. Finally, I'd like to hear which option is most suitable for your situation and why.

Therefore, with this goal in mind, let's start with the pros of freestanding bathtubs.

The Pros of Freestanding Tubs

Pro 1-The freestanding bathtub makes the bathroom look larger without creating a "closed" feeling

Since freestanding bathtubs are not built in corners or alcoves, you can see around them. They actually show more bathroom floors and make the bathroom (at least visually) bigger.

Even a small bathroom will feel more open, and you won't feel trapped in a narrow alcove when taking a bath.

Pro 2- Freestanding tubs are more comfortable than alcove tubs

Since most freestanding bathtubs are about 30% deeper than alcove bathtubs, they can hold more water. In addition, they provide more interior space (which is a great benefit for the tall people in your family).

Pro3- they have (seemingly) unlimited design, shape and size, and can be matched with any decoration

Whether you are looking for classic and elegant Single Slipper bathtubs in traditional families or looking for white retro clawfoot bathtubs in modern families, or avant-garde contemporary acrylic soaking bathtubs, you can find a variety of design options.

With a freestanding tub – there’s no reason to settle for plain and boring.

Pro4- There’s a wide range of material options to choose from

If you like the antique cast iron claw foot bathtub, or the durability of solid surface bathtub, or the fashionable elegance of acrylic freestanding bathtub, these are all possible.

And now – to be balanced, let’s look at the cons of freestanding tubs.

The Cons of Freestanding Tubs

Con1- They’re more expensive than alcove tubs

Even though you have to add the cost of framing, alcove tubs are still significantly less expensive than a freestanding tub.

Con2- They can be heavy

If you choose a solid surface tub you need to know they’re heavy and can require additional support underneath your subfloor. However, if you want a freestanding tub, but don’t want to add structural reinforcements, a smart alternative is an acrylic freestanding bathtub.

The Pros of an Alcove Tub

Pro1- Alcove bathtub is cheaper than freestanding bathtub

Because Alcove bathtubs are not as big as freestanding bathtubs, or they are not decorated on all sides, you will find that they are much cheaper than freestanding bathtubs.

Pro2-They use less water

Although alcove bathtubs vary greatly in height, depth and design, it is a common fact that alcove bathtubs can hold much less water than freestanding bathtubs. If you focus on saving water, this is an advantage.

Pro3- Easier storage  

If you like most people, you want to have enough space for soap, shampoo and face cream, but because of the freestanding bathtub discussed above, your supplies space is limited (or even not). Select an alcove bathtub to open a space in the shower wall and put a built-in storage rack.

Pro4- You can add bypass tub doors or walk in tub glass to keep the water inside

Since alcove tubs are butted to one or more walls, you can add a bypass glass tub door or walk in glass tub enclosure. This will keep the water inside – where you want it to be.

The Cons of an Alcove Tub

Con1- Alcove tubs need to be placed against the walls

Because alcove bathtubs are placed against the wall, they do not give you (almost) unlimited options for placing freestanding bathtubs.

Con2- You may need to build a framed wall to enclose your alcove bathtub

If your alcove bathtub has unfinished walls, you will need to pay extra to build them. In a small transformation, the cost may be greater than you think.

So, do you prefer freestanding bathtubs or alcove bathtubs? Can we-WOODBRIDG help you decide the best option and/or quote for the project?

If you are still difficult to decide, or need the price of these options, please go to our product home page or call 562-229-0088 or click on free design consultation.